skip to content rich footer

stevenclark.com.au

subscibe to the StevenClark.com.au rss feed

Archive for December, 2009

What Killed the Occidental Production Managers?

Thursday, December 31st, 2009

We hear a lot about the business shooting stars that graduate from Occidental MBA (Master of Business Administration) programs. Hell, I’m most of the way through an MBA myself and it does provide a good grounding for doing business in the larger corporation. But are business schools really doing us proud; or are they killing off the old style production managers?

Noam Schetber, senior editor on The New Republic, wrote an article several weeks ago titled Upper Mismanagement that has been sitting open in my Firefox browser awaiting some form of logical comment. As an MBA student with certain ideas about a moral obligation to other societies, the environment and to the greater good (while still turning a profit) its more than obvious from my perspective that all’s not well in shooting star land. As Schetber rightly points out, MBAs are being trained to see corporations as assets to be valued rather than as vibrant production environments. They are training financial soldiors at the cost of a depleting resource of those who can actually run industrial companies.

Let’s step back a minute… Schetber is suggesting that we’re losing the innovation opportunities that a production manager would support (such as you would see in Japanese companies) because business schools are focusing on the finance… which may not only explain the movement away from production in the United States and Australia but also our obsession with constant rationalisation as a never-ending scoop of in-house resources back into the bottom-line.

Let me put it this way… nearly every unit in an MBA program will tell the student that the purpose of a business is the maximisation of shareholder wealth. But is it? You may find one unit in there that says the purpose of business is to fulfil social needs not served by government and a motivation behind that (as well as a logical off-shoot of it) is that the business makes money, it turns a profit. Think about that for a minute. What are you in business for if you’re a company making chairs… you’re in the business of serving the needs of people who need chairs. So you specialise, innovate and look for win-win situations that provide economic benefit. That makes much more sense in the real world than the maximisation of shareholder wealth.

Read the rest of this entry »

Social Networking

Keep an eye out for me on Twitter

About the Author

Steven Clark Steven Clark - the stand up guy on this site

My name is Steven Clark (aka nortypig) and my passions are business, web development, photography and writing. My current CV [PDF 775KB] is available for download. Currently I'm completing my 2 final units of a post-graduate university degree of MBA (Journalism and Media Studies) at the University of Tasmania.

Photography

My fine art photography is available online at Steven Clark Studio. You may also enjoy my photo blog Walk a Mile in my Shoes.

Recently Reviewed Books

Site Supporters

Hosted by Brett Drinkwater at Tashosting who is always there at the other end of my every inconvenient question and technical crisis. Brett's local community support for us over the last five years is greatly appreciated.

skip to top of page

Currently Reading

Light Science and Magic by Hunter, Biver and Fuqua - cover

The time has come for me to get more involved in upping my technical photography skills if I hope to embark on a Master of Fine Art and Design (Photography) next year. To that end my first book is the highly recommended Light Science & Magic: An Introduction to Photographic Lighting (Third Edition) by Fil Hunter, Steven Biver and Paul Fuqua. What really differentiates this book is the comprehensive set of exercises and the detailed explanation of the underlying science of light in the real world that encompasses the reader's journey.