skip to content rich footer

stevenclark.com.au

subscibe to the StevenClark.com.au rss feed

Culture, Remixing and Ideas

Remix by Lawrence Lessig (cover)It’s called culture. We’re ten years old and stand on the back steps with our friends miming the latest pop songs. We’re twenty years old and we’re burning a mixed CD for our girlfriend / boyfriend to share something of who we are through the compilation. We’re 80 years old and we want to play Johnny Cash songs at our funeral…

Stanford professor and lawyer Lawrence Lessig released his latest book called Remix: Making art and commerce thrive in the hybrid economy late in 2008 and this week it became available as a free Creative Commons download via Bloomsbury Academic. A pre-eminant authority in the ongoing copyfight debate, it’s finally great to grab a copy of this for my upcoming holiday reading list.

RIP: A Remix Manifesto offers up a strong perspective on the remix society we’re living in. Are we reduced to consumers of culture for the next century or more? Have we created a generation (or three) of criminals by default? At what point does the grey line between sharing culture and protecting artist rights work best for society as a whole? No single person or business should stand above the greater good of the society we share. In fact, we remix in society every single day – so are we all criminals?

The most significant case that’s run across my radar in recent times has been the Shepard Fairey v Associated Press wrangle over the Mannie Garcia photo used as a basis for the now ubiquitous Obama poster – HOPE. It points out to a lot of artists that fair use is a legal issue, rather than a God given right to grab. Also, Fairey himself has used copyright to cease and desist another artist, Baxter Orr, who remixed Fairey’s OBEY poster several years ago. Something which received a decent critique, by the way.

Another photographer, Jim Krantz, was the guy who took the famous Malboro Man front on shot of the rodeo rider on the bucking horse. He walked into the Guggenheim and found Richard Prince was exhibiting his work – Prince blows up advertising photographs to larger scale. In 2007, the New York Times asked If the Copy is an Artwork, Then Whats the Original?

So the Fairey case is one to watch. On the one hand we need to be able to re-use the stuff around us to experience and be involved in culture (as opposed to final consumers) and we need the real interests of artists and content creators to be appreciated in the copyright laws of tomorrow. The current state of lockdown is oppressive… it’s unsustainable… it’s about big business owning and keeping assets.

Another free Creative Commons download worth reading on the subject is Professor James Boyle’s The Public Domain: Enclosing the Commons of the Mind. Understanding what copyright was intended to achieve and how it has evolved to this current state is a critical part of seeing where the line should be drawn.

As for Fairey? Well I’m on the fence with that one nowdays because the case has pros and cons on both sides and I’m waiting to hear more from the courtroom. Perhaps it’s a line ball? As for DRM (Digital Rights Management) – even the lawyers admit DRM is the most reviled consumer technology of the market today.

Comments are closed.

Social Networking

Keep an eye out for me on Twitter

About the Author

Steven Clark Steven Clark - the stand up guy on this site

My name is Steven Clark (aka nortypig) and my passions are business, web development, photography and writing. I have an MBA (Specialisation) and a Bachelor of Computing from the University of Tasmania. I am working as a business management consultant.

Photography

My photography is at Steven Clark Studio and my regular photo blog presents an ongoing stream of latest images at Walk a Mile in my Shoes and I'm working on a long-term photography project called the King Island Project.

Recently Reviewed Books

Site Supporters

Hosted by Brett Drinkwater at Tashosting who is always there at the other end of my every inconvenient question and technical crisis. Brett's local community support for us over the last five years is greatly appreciated.

skip to top of page

Currently Reading

Ansel Adams: The Camera

As the first of three parts of Ansel Adams Photography Series, Ansel Adams: The Camera begins by discussing the idea of visualisation in relation to photography. Ansel Adams is a master of his craft; this series has sat on my backburner for some time. Book 2 in this series is The Negative and it's followed up by The Print. In them Ansel outlines his philosophy of photography rather than trying to lay down a set of rules. This first instalment is a technical book that explains the good old fashion film camera.