skip to content rich footer

stevenclark.com.au

subscibe to the StevenClark.com.au rss feed

Creative Commons Images: Black or White?

If you’re a contractor or a sub-contractor in the web industry you will probably have run into the contentious issue of creative commons images. While clients may have some photography to pass over to you it’s more often than not an unpolished resource taken on average equipment. That leaves you the options of stock photography from iStockphoto or Getty Images, for example, or what I personally consider the murky world of creative commons images. In my experience, the pressure usually gets weighted toward the free creative commons images that can be easily grabbed by designers from sites like Flickr.

My concerns about using Flickr images are perfectly valid once you have a scroll and try a few searches. It becomes quickly apparent that most people aren’t even aware on Flickr that their images could be used in a commercial environment. Yes you can probably legally use images of their children at the beach or someone’s beautiful photograph of a farm area - but ethically? Are you trying to tell me that every parent with a child on Flickr has granted you the license - I’m talking morally - to use their home photos commercially? I’m not talking about the legal right, I mean in the real world of human beings.

I don’t know why nobody seems to get this issue. Are we, as a civilisation, reduced to the generalised acceptance that something legal is therefore right? Can anyone who reads this even accept that most people who upload images to a resource like Flickr simply don’t read the terms of service or pay attention to their privacy selections?

No, in my personal opinion, Flickr is not the free resource for creative commons stock photography that will save you the few bucks that should be spent on professional stock photography. And, if you’re going to use those images then at least contact the owners and ask permission, supply the correct attribution and make sure they’re in total agreeance with what you’re about to use their work to promote. Would you like to find your partner’s photograph as a banner on a porn blog? People deserve the same respect that you’re expecting for yourself.

The option that most often works for me is to keep a stock photography resource of my own original work. On most low-end work this resource gives me enough to work with, but my next step failing that is to visit a professional stock photography resource. The only time I have used Flickr as a resource was under the duress of the person I was subcontracting for, and it made me feel dirty. In my opinion, Flickr only became an option to save a few bucks. Simple.

So, before you go grab everyone’s creative commons photography, give some thought to the grey part of that enterprise. Ask yourself if you’ve been entirely ethical with the photographer and the subjects in the work. Contact the original owner.

I needn’t point out that the Flickr account owner may have stolen the image and just uploaded it, either. It’s something to think about when you’re putting your own personal reputation as a designer onto the table. Who does own the work?

Food for thought. It’s not as black and white as legal or illegal usage. Three billion images on Flickr equals an awful lot of ordinary people who deserve better from our industry.

Leave a Reply

NOTE: fields marked with an asterisk * are required.





Stand Up Guy

Steven Clark Steven Clark - the stand up guy on this site

An icon for overweight middle aged bogun-geek web designers. A lego block in a Meccano world. A synergy of tattoos, memories of bare knuckle fist fights, and old episodes of Star Trek. My name is Steven Clark and I'm a highly opinionated web designer with a few good ideas. I'm too old for fist fights.

My Photography Blog

My photography blog Walk a Mile in my Shoes is back up and running. Due to bandwidth issues it's only one image at a time and not full text in the RSS feed. It's licensed under creative commons , meaning not for commercial use and you need to attribute, otherwise drop me a line via the contact form on this site.

My Links Blog

You might also like to check out my links blog over at Nortypig.com to learn more about everything worth mentioning.

My Illustrations

Currently I only have a static page for illustrations but if time allows I'd like to start another illustration blog.

Declaration of Independence

Site Content

Developed and published by Steven Clark

Site Supporters

Hosted by Brett at Tashosting

skip to top of page

Currently Reading

Here Comes Everybody by Clay Shirky (cover)

Clay Shirky's Here Comes Everybody: The Power of Organizing without Organizations has been on my bookshelf for the last few months literally screaming to be read. In fact, I'm wondering how I got so sidetracked to have reached the end of the year without having consumed it. The message of the book is an area of my own fascination, the effects that our new technologies have on the way we relate to each other, and how we're now empowered in ways that were historically unheard of (or not even conceived of) not too long ago.

I'm a small town boy who grew up in the seventies, graduating high school in 1979. The world was slower - how did we survive without Wikipedia? Without MSN or Facebook? Nowdays we have flashmobbing and blogging and constant connection.