skip to content rich footer

stevenclark.com.au

subscibe to the StevenClark.com.au rss feed

Archive for February, 2008

IE8 - Why Not Strict Instead of Meta?

Tuesday, February 26th, 2008

Have you listened to the WaSP Round Table: IE8’s Default Version Targeting Behaviour? It’s also available as an mp3 and as a transcript. Its an interesting discussion between Web Standards Project Members Faruk Ates, Aaron Gustafson, and Porter Glendinning with Chris Wilson, Platform Architect for Internet Explorer.

Some of the conversation will come as no surprise at all. But right at the end the WaSP guys asked whether it would be worth exploring the requirement of a Strict Doctype as a switch for indicating standards mode? They discussed the investigation of market penetration of Strict Doctypes and the use of a full URL after it. This sounds like a much more interesting proposal than the opt-in meta tag solution being put forward at the moment. I see that Roger Johansson has also posted his support for using Strict Doctypes to signal standards mode.

Doctypes generated by DreamWeaver and other applications tend to auto-generate as Transitional. These could be treated very differently to those pages specifically saying they want to be treated in standards mode - which you’re generally saying when you go to Strict anyway. It makes a logical sense I don’t think is there with the proposed meta tag opt-in solution. And, without anything to back this statement up, how many of the Internet Explorer Only intranets that seem to be the economic concern of Microsoft actually use Strict Doctypes anyway?

Logically, maybe even naively, if they did happen to have a (probably very invalid) Strict Doctype when IE8 came out wouldn’t this solution simply require them to change to a Transitional Doctype?

Originally I wrote my initial negative response to the proposed meta tag solution and then my pragmatic acceptance only several days ago. That being said I’m very interested in this proposition put forward at the WaSP Round Table. Why not Strict Doctypes instead of Meta? And I’m sure standaristas will accept the marketing much better?

skip to top of page

Currently Reading

Mental Models by Indi Young (cover)Developing software from the user's perspective as opposed the organisational one is a critical area we need to work on as designers. I'm reading Mental Models by Indi Young, a book about understanding users' reasons for doing things and one system for understanding and designing for those reasons.

It's important to understand that when people visit your website they bring with them their own world view, motivations, experience and expectations. And, by working with those factors, we can improve our game significantly by providing them with what they want and need.